Planoly vs Buffer

Planoly vs Buffer for Pinterest Pins

If you are comparing Planoly and Buffer, you are probably trying to figure out which one will help you create and schedule Pinterest pins faster. Both tools can post to Pinterest, but their approach to pin creation, scheduling, and automation is very different.

Planoly positions itself as a visual planner for instagram and pinterest. Planoly started as an Instagram visual planner and expanded to Pinterest. It offers a clean grid-based planning view, basic scheduling, and a simple content calendar. Pinterest support was added later and feels secondary to Instagram features. For Pinterest specifically, Pinterest is one of several platforms it supports, not its primary focus.

Buffer, on the other hand, is a simple, affordable social media scheduling. Buffer is one of the simplest social media scheduling tools available. It supports Pinterest along with other major platforms, offering a clean queue-based approach to scheduling. Known for its ease of use and transparent pricing. When it comes to Pinterest pins, it handles basic pin scheduling but is not built specifically for Pinterest growth.

Pin Creation and Design Features

Neither tool is a Pinterest specialist, to be honest. Planoly treats Pinterest as one of several supported platforms. Buffer offers basic support. If Pinterest is your main growth channel, keep that in mind.

For pin design, Planoly provides Basic templates. Buffer does not include pin templates either. BlogToPin includes 100+ templates that automatically generate unique pin designs from your content.

Board management is available in Planoly and available in Buffer. Being able to organize and manage boards from your scheduling tool saves time, especially if you run multiple Pinterest accounts or manage boards for different niches.

Pin Scheduling Workflow

Your daily workflow will look different depending on which tool you pick. Planoly uses manual scheduling without optimal time suggestions. Buffer leaves timing decisions up to you.

When it comes to volume, Planoly only allows one-by-one scheduling. Buffer also requires individual scheduling for each pin. If you are pinning 20+ times a day (which many Pinterest strategists recommend), bulk capabilities matter.

AI-Powered Pin Generation

AI is becoming table stakes for social media tools in 2026. Planoly includes AI Caption for generating captions and descriptions. Buffer offers AI Assistant to help with content creation.

BlogToPin's AI goes further than both. It does not just help you write descriptions. It reads your actual blog post or product page, understands the content, and writes Pinterest-optimized titles and descriptions that include relevant keywords. The AI also selects the best images from your content and generates multiple pin variations automatically.

Pricing for Pinterest Marketers

Planoly starts at $16/mo (tiered plans with upload limits). Buffer comes in at $6/mo per channel (per channel pricing).

The pricing is pretty close, so this comparison really comes down to features rather than cost. Both are in a similar ballpark.

Buffer offers a free plan, so you can try it before committing. That said, free plans usually have tight limits that will not work for serious Pinterest marketing.

BlogToPin starts at $39/mo for the Starter plan, which includes 1,000+ pins per month, unlimited AI generation, and auto-creation from your website. When you factor in the time saved (most users save 5-10 hours per week on pin creation), the ROI makes a lot of sense. There is also a free trial so you can test it with your own content.

The Pin Creation Bottleneck

Here is the real problem with Pinterest growth that neither Planoly nor Buffer solves: creating pins is slow. Pinterest rewards volume — the more unique pins you publish, the more chances you have to rank in search and get distribution. Most Pinterest strategists recommend 15-25 fresh pins per day. That means designing images, writing keyword-rich titles, crafting descriptions, and scheduling to the right boards.

Both Planoly and Buffer help with the scheduling part, but you still have to create every single pin by hand. Upload an image, write a title, craft a description, pick a board, repeat. For one or two pins, that is fine. For 100+ pins a week? That is hours of work.

BlogToPin solves this differently. Instead of making you create each pin manually, it reads your website (blog posts, product pages, any content) and generates pins automatically. AI writes Pinterest-optimized titles with keywords. 100+ templates create visual variety so your profile does not look like the same pin copied 500 times. Smart scheduling distributes pins across optimal times.

There is another pin management problem neither tool addresses: underperforming pins. Pinterest's algorithm actually penalizes accounts with lots of low-engagement pins. BlogToPin can automatically identify and delete these pins, improving your overall account quality and giving your good pins better distribution.

If you are spending more than 30 minutes a week creating and scheduling pins, that is time you could spend on actual content creation. Scheduling is only half the problem — the other half is generating enough quality pins in the first place.

Which Is Better for Your Pinterest Strategy?

Pick Planoly for your Pinterest pins if instagram-first creators who also post to pinterest, or if visual planners who want a clean grid view, or if beginners who value simplicity over power features. It is a solid tool that handles Pinterest pin scheduling alongside other platforms and will not break the bank.

Go with Buffer for Pinterest if beginners who want the simplest possible tool, or if solo creators on a tight budget, or if people who need basic scheduling across many platforms. Pinterest is not their primary focus, but pin scheduling works fine and the price is right.

Choose BlogToPin if you have a website (blog, online store, any content site) and want to generate Pinterest pins on autopilot. No other tool in this comparison creates pins from your content automatically. If you are spending hours each week designing pin images, writing titles, and scheduling by hand, that is the real cost you should be calculating — not the monthly subscription price.