Pin Generator vs Planoly
Dedicated pin creator versus Instagram planner for Pinterest
TL;DR
For Pinterest pin creation: Pin Generator creates pins in bulk at ~$9/mo, Planoly is an Instagram planner at $11.25/mo. Pin Generator is far more useful for Pinterest — it actually creates pins. BlogToPin adds full blog-to-pin automation.
Key Differences for Pinterest
How these tools differ for Pinterest pin creation and scheduling
Pinterest Focus
Pin Generator has a Pinterest rating of 6/10 while Planoly scores 5/10. Pin Generator offers stronger Pinterest-specific features.
Pricing
Pin Generator starts at $19/mo while Planoly starts at $16/mo.
Bulk Pin Creation
Neither Pin Generator nor Planoly can generate pins from your website automatically. BlogToPin reads your sitemap and creates hundreds of optimized pins with AI-written titles and descriptions.
Platform Support
Pin Generator supports Pinterest only (design). Planoly covers Instagram, Pinterest, TikTok, Facebook. Planoly gives you more platform options.
Analytics
Planoly provides deeper Pinterest analytics. Planoly offers basic analytics while the other has more basic reporting.
Pricing for Pinterest Users
What you will actually pay for Pinterest pin scheduling
Pin Generator
Per pin volume
Planoly
Tiered plans with upload limits
BlogToPin
Starter plan. 1,000+ pins/mo. Unlimited AI.
Pinterest Feature Comparison
20 Pinterest-relevant features compared side-by-side
| Feature | Pin Generator | Planoly | BlogToPin |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pinterest Features | |||
| Pinterest Scheduling | |||
| Smart Schedule | AI-powered | ||
| Pin Templates | Auto-generated | Basic templates | 100+ templates |
| Board Management | Basic | ||
| Idea & Video Pins | Limited | ||
| Automation | |||
| Bulk Scheduling | Automatic | ||
| Auto-Create from URL | Design only | ||
| Auto-Sync New Content | |||
| Content Recycling | |||
| Delete Underperforming Pins | |||
| RSS Feed Integration | |||
| AI & Content | |||
| AI Writing | AI Caption | Unlimited | |
| AI Image Generation | |||
| Hashtag Suggestions | |||
| Analytics | |||
| Pinterest Analytics | Basic | ||
| Best Time to Post | |||
| Competitor Tracking | |||
| Platform | |||
| Multi-Platform | Pinterest only (design) | Instagram, Pinterest, TikTok, Facebook | Pinterest focused |
| Mobile App | |||
| Team Collaboration | Paid add-on | Business plan | |
Pros & Cons for Pinterest
Strengths and weaknesses for Pinterest pin workflows
Pin Generator
Pros
- Automatically creates pin images from your blog posts
- Multiple templates for design variety
- Saves time vs manually designing each pin in Canva
- Pulls text and images from your URLs automatically
- Good for bloggers with lots of content to turn into pins
Cons
- No scheduling, analytics, or board management
- Design quality can be hit or miss
- Limited template customization options
- Still need another tool for scheduling the pins
- No AI writing for descriptions or titles
- Cannot handle the full Pinterest workflow
Planoly
Pros
- Beautiful visual grid planner for planning your feed
- Easy to learn with a clean, minimal interface
- Good Instagram planning tools that translate okay to Pinterest
- Decent mobile app for planning on the go
- Affordable entry point for beginners
Cons
- Pinterest features clearly secondary to Instagram
- Strict upload limits even on paid plans
- No content recycling or automation features
- Analytics are very basic
- No smart scheduling or optimal time suggestions
- Cannot create pins from website content
BlogToPin
Pros
- Auto-creates pins from your website content — no manual design
- 100+ pin templates for visual variety across your profile
- AI writes Pinterest-optimized titles and descriptions
- Automatically deletes underperforming pins to protect account quality
- Smart scheduling posts pins at optimal times
- Reads your sitemap and generates pins from every page
Cons
- Pinterest-only — does not support other social platforms
- No mobile app yet
- Requires a website with content to generate pins from
- Starting at $39/mo, higher entry price than basic schedulers
What Users Say
Real user reviews from Trustpilot and G2
Planoly Reviews
“I have been using Planoly for 5+ years and have always had a good experience with them.”
“Planoly quietly charged me over $500 across 6 years with no renewal reminders, no usage reports.”
Best For Pinterest
When to choose each tool for your Pinterest pin strategy
Pin Generator
- Bloggers who want automated pin design without manual work
- Content creators who have lots of posts but no time to design
- Pinterest users who need a design tool paired with a separate scheduler
Planoly
- Instagram-first creators who also post to Pinterest
- Visual planners who want a clean grid view
- Beginners who value simplicity over power features
BlogToPin
- You need hundreds of unique pins created from your website content
- You want AI to write Pinterest-optimized titles and descriptions
- You are tired of manually designing pin images for every post
- You want to automatically remove underperforming pins
- You need Pinterest pin creation on autopilot, not just scheduling
Overview
Pin Generator and Planoly serve completely different Pinterest needs. Pin Generator creates pins with templates and bulk generation — the core Pinterest challenge. Planoly is an Instagram visual planner with basic Pinterest scheduling. For Pinterest marketing, creation is the bottleneck, making Pin Generator immediately more relevant.
Pin Creation
Pin Generator creates Pinterest pins with templates, batch generation, and multiple variations — directly addressing the production bottleneck.
Planoly has no pin creation tools. Its visual grid planner is designed for Instagram, and pins must be designed externally.
Pinterest Focus
Pin Generator is 100% Pinterest-focused. Planoly is Instagram-first with Pinterest as secondary.
For Pinterest marketing, Pin Generator's focused approach delivers more relevant features.
Pricing
Pin Generator at ~$9/mo is cheaper and more Pinterest-useful. Planoly at $11.25/mo costs more for Instagram-focused features.
For Pinterest spending, Pin Generator provides better value.
Full Automation
Pin Generator speeds up manual creation. Neither automates from blog content.
BlogToPin automates the full blog-to-pin pipeline — reading content and generating complete pins automatically.
Final Verdict
Pin Generator is more useful for Pinterest at a lower price. Planoly is for Instagram users wanting basic Pinterest scheduling.
BlogToPin provides full automation from blog content, going beyond Pin Generator's batch approach.
Want pins created automatically?
Both Pin Generator and Planoly require manual pin creation. BlogToPin generates pins from your website with AI — no design work needed.
Frequently Asked Questions
6 questions answered about Pin Generator vs Planoly
Can Planoly create Pinterest pins or just schedule them?
Planoly cannot create Pinterest pins. It is an Instagram-first visual planner that offers basic Pinterest scheduling. You need to design your pins externally in tools like Canva before uploading them to Planoly. Pin Generator, by contrast, creates pins directly with templates and bulk generation.
Which is cheaper for Pinterest marketing, Pin Generator or Planoly?
Pin Generator is cheaper at roughly $9/mo compared to Planoly at $11.25/mo. Pin Generator also delivers more Pinterest-specific value since it actually creates pins, whereas Planoly's features are primarily built for Instagram content planning.
Is Planoly good for Pinterest if I already use it for Instagram?
Planoly works as a basic Pinterest scheduler if you already have a subscription for Instagram. However, it lacks pin creation tools, Pinterest-specific templates, and bulk generation. For serious Pinterest marketing, you will need a dedicated tool like Pin Generator or BlogToPin alongside Planoly.
How does Pin Generator handle bulk pin creation compared to Planoly?
Pin Generator supports batch generation with templates, letting you create multiple pin variations at once. Planoly has no bulk creation features for Pinterest — every pin must be designed externally and uploaded individually. For high-volume Pinterest strategies, Pin Generator saves significant time.
Can I automate blog-to-pin creation with either tool?
Neither Pin Generator nor Planoly automates pin creation from blog content. Pin Generator speeds up manual creation with batch tools, and Planoly only handles scheduling. BlogToPin fills this gap by reading your blog posts and automatically generating complete pins with descriptions.
Which tool should I choose if Pinterest is my primary marketing channel?
Pin Generator is the clear choice. It is 100% Pinterest-focused with templates and bulk creation tools. Planoly treats Pinterest as a secondary platform behind Instagram. If you want full automation from blog content, BlogToPin is the most efficient option for Pinterest-first marketers.
Tired of creating pins by hand?
BlogToPin generates Pinterest pins from your website automatically. AI writes the titles and descriptions, 100+ templates handle design, and smart scheduling posts at optimal times. Try it free.