Buffer vs Metricool
Clean pin scheduling versus analytics-powered Pinterest management
TL;DR
For Pinterest pin creation: Buffer is the cleanest pin scheduler from $6/month per channel ($5/month billed annually) — schedule and forget. Metricool bundles scheduling with detailed Pinterest analytics, best-time recommendations, RSS, and Autolists recycling from $25/month ($20/month billed annually), plus a free plan. Buffer is the purist's scheduler. Metricool is for data-driven pinners who want analytics alongside scheduling. Neither designs pins for you.
Key Differences for Pinterest
How these tools differ for Pinterest pin creation and scheduling
Pinterest Focus
Buffer has a Pinterest rating of 4/10 while Metricool scores 6/10. Metricool offers stronger Pinterest-specific features.
Pricing
Buffer starts at $6/mo per channel ($5 billed annually) while Metricool starts at $25/mo ($20/mo billed annually). Buffer offers a free plan. Metricool offers a free plan.
Automation
Metricool has Autolists. Neither tool can auto-create pins from your website content like BlogToPin does.
Bulk Pin Creation
Neither Buffer nor Metricool can generate pins from your website automatically. BlogToPin reads your sitemap and creates hundreds of optimized pins with AI-written titles and descriptions.
Analytics
Metricool provides deeper Pinterest analytics. Metricool offers detailed analytics while the other has more basic reporting.
Pricing for Pinterest Users
What you will actually pay for Pinterest pin scheduling
Buffer
Per channel pricing
Metricool
Tiered plans by number of brands
BlogToPin
Starter plan. 1,000+ pins/mo. Unlimited AI.
Pinterest Feature Comparison
20 Pinterest-relevant features compared side-by-side
| Feature | Buffer | Metricool | BlogToPin |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pinterest Features | |||
| Pinterest Scheduling | |||
| Smart Schedule | Best Times | AI-powered | |
| Pin Templates | 100+ templates | ||
| Board Management | Basic | Basic | |
| Idea & Video Pins | Image, video & GIF pins | Image & video pins | |
| Automation | |||
| Bulk Scheduling | CSV bulk upload | CSV import | Automatic |
| Auto-Create from URL | |||
| Auto-Sync New Content | |||
| Content Recycling | Autolists | ||
| Delete Underperforming Pins | |||
| RSS Feed Integration | Ideas only (no auto-post) | ||
| AI & Content | |||
| AI Writing | AI Assistant | AI Assistant | Unlimited |
| AI Image Generation | |||
| Hashtag Suggestions | Hashtag search (paid) | ||
| Analytics | |||
| Pinterest Analytics | Basic | Detailed | |
| Best Time to Post | |||
| Competitor Tracking | Not for Pinterest | ||
| Platform | |||
| Multi-Platform | Instagram, Facebook, TikTok, LinkedIn, X, YouTube, Threads, Pinterest, Google Business, Bluesky, Mastodon | Facebook, Instagram, Threads, Bluesky, Pinterest, TikTok, YouTube, Twitch, Google Business, LinkedIn (paid), X (add-on) | Pinterest focused |
| Mobile App | |||
| Team Collaboration | Team plan | Advanced plan | Business plan |
Pros & Cons for Pinterest
Strengths and weaknesses for Pinterest pin workflows
Buffer
Pros
- Dead simple to use, almost no learning curve
- Very affordable, especially for solo creators
- Supports more platforms than most tools
- Clean, distraction-free interface
- Free plan for 3 channels and 10 scheduled posts per channel
- Great for beginners who just need basic scheduling
Cons
- Pinterest features are extremely basic
- No Pinterest-specific best-time data
- No pin design templates (Canva integration only)
- No content recycling or evergreen features
- Analytics are minimal for Pinterest
- No pin recycling or auto-pinning from your site (CSV bulk upload only)
Metricool
Pros
- Best analytics in its price range, especially for Pinterest
- Competitor benchmarking for Instagram, Facebook, YouTube and more (not Pinterest)
- RSS feeds and Autolists keep a queue of posts going
- Free plan for one brand, limited to 20 scheduled posts a month
- Best time to post suggestions based on your data
- Clean dashboard with actionable insights
Cons
- Scheduling features are secondary to analytics
- No pin design tools or templates
- Recycling via Autolists and RSS, but no Pinterest-specific automation
- Cannot create pins from website content
- Bulk scheduling limited to CSV import
- Some advanced analytics locked behind higher plans
BlogToPin
Pros
- Auto-creates pins from your website content — no manual design
- 100+ pin templates for visual variety across your profile
- AI writes Pinterest-optimized titles and descriptions
- Automatically deletes underperforming pins to protect account quality
- Smart scheduling posts pins at optimal times
- Reads your sitemap and generates pins from every page
Cons
- Pinterest-only — does not support other social platforms
- No mobile app yet
- Requires a website with content to generate pins from
- Starting at $39/mo, higher entry price than basic schedulers
What Users Say
Real user reviews from Trustpilot and G2
Buffer Reviews
“Buffer saves me so much time. Tools are efficient and easy to use, easy to swap out accounts and channels too.”
“I've scheduled 5 posts every day but one post doesn't always get published because it exceeded the number of posts allowed.”
Metricool Reviews
“I've used Metricool now for over a year, and run over 30 different brands from their platform. Their support team is fantastic.”
“The software simply does not work and customer support is unresponsive, unreliable, and they do not value customers' time.”
Best For Pinterest
When to choose each tool for your Pinterest pin strategy
Buffer
- Beginners who want the simplest possible tool
- Solo creators on a tight budget
- People who need basic scheduling across many platforms
Metricool
- Data-driven marketers who want deep Pinterest analytics
- Multi-network brands that want competitor benchmarks on Instagram and Facebook
- Budget-conscious users who want analytics plus scheduling
BlogToPin
- You need hundreds of unique pins created from your website content
- You want AI to write Pinterest-optimized titles and descriptions
- You are tired of manually designing pin images for every post
- You want to automatically remove underperforming pins
- You need Pinterest pin creation on autopilot, not just scheduling
Overview
For Pinterest marketers, Buffer and Metricool offer different balances of scheduling and analytics. Buffer does scheduling perfectly and analytics adequately. Metricool does analytics impressively and scheduling competently. If your Pinterest challenge is maintaining a consistent pinning schedule with minimal fuss, Buffer is the faster tool. If your challenge is understanding which pins drive traffic and when to post, Metricool gives you data that Buffer cannot match — at a reasonable price with a usable free tier.
Pinterest Analytics and Insights
Metricool's Pinterest analytics go well beyond basic post metrics. You get pin-level performance data, board analytics, engagement rate trends, follower growth charts, and best-time-to-post recommendations based on when your actual audience is most active. The dashboard presents this data in visual charts that make it easy to spot patterns — which pin designs drive the most saves, which boards generate the most traffic, and which days see the highest engagement.
Buffer's Pinterest analytics cover post-level performance: clicks, engagement, and reach for each published pin. You can identify your top-performing pins and see a summary of recent performance. The data is actionable but surface-level. You won't find trend analysis, audience activity patterns, or board-level insights in Buffer.
For Pinterest marketers who want to optimize their strategy based on data — testing different pin designs, refining posting times, understanding seasonal engagement patterns — Metricool provides significantly more to work with. For those who schedule pins and trust their intuition, Buffer's basic analytics confirm what's working without overwhelming detail.
Recycling and Content Sources
Metricool's Autolists recycle evergreen content on a schedule, so proven pins can keep going out without manual rescheduling. It can also pull new posts from RSS feeds and import posts via CSV. Its competitor tracking, however, does not cover Pinterest.
Buffer doesn't recycle pins — each pin is scheduled once — and its RSS support is limited to showing feed items as ideas rather than auto-posting them. It does support CSV bulk upload with a board column for Pinterest. Neither tool tracks Pinterest competitors.
Recycling is particularly valuable on Pinterest because pins can drive traffic for months. If you have a library of evergreen pins, Metricool's Autolists keep them circulating; with Buffer, you'd re-add them yourself.
Best Time to Pin
Metricool analyzes your audience's activity patterns and recommends optimal posting times specifically for Pinterest. Instead of guessing when to pin or relying on generic "best times to post on Pinterest" blog articles, you get recommendations based on when your specific audience is most active and engaged. This data-driven scheduling can meaningfully improve pin visibility and engagement.
Buffer lets you set your own posting time slots and shows generic recommended times, but nothing specific to your Pinterest audience. You configure your schedule based on your own research or intuition. While this gives you full control, you're missing the data that could tell you whether your chosen times are actually optimal for your audience.
Free Plans for Pinterest
Metricool's free plan covers one brand with up to 20 posts per month across platforms including Pinterest, plus basic analytics. You can manage a small Pinterest presence without paying anything. The free tier provides enough analytics to understand your pin performance basics.
Buffer's free plan includes three social channels with up to ten scheduled posts per channel. The scheduling experience is unrestricted but the queue size is limited. Both free plans are genuinely usable for small-scale Pinterest management.
For Pinterest marketers who want analytics alongside scheduling at no cost, Metricool's free plan offers more data. For those who just want clean scheduling, Buffer's free plan provides a smoother daily workflow.
Pin Scheduling Workflow
Buffer's scheduling remains the fastest in the category. Compose, attach pin image, write description, select board, add to queue. Under a minute per pin. The queue automatically fills your time slots. For batch-scheduling 20+ pins in a sitting, Buffer's speed advantage is noticeable.
Metricool's scheduling includes a visual calendar with drag-and-drop and analytics-suggested posting times. The interface is slightly busier than Buffer's due to the analytics features visible alongside the calendar. Once familiar with the layout, scheduling is efficient, though not quite as fast as Buffer's stripped-down queue.
If you schedule pins daily and want the fastest possible process, Buffer saves cumulative time. If you schedule weekly and want analytics data visible while planning your pin schedule, Metricool's integrated view keeps everything in context.
Final Verdict
Buffer is the best choice for Pinterest marketers who want the fastest, most affordable scheduling experience. At $6/month per channel, it handles pin scheduling with zero complexity. If you check basic pin performance occasionally and trust your strategy, Buffer keeps you focused on scheduling rather than data analysis.
Metricool is the smarter choice for data-driven Pinterest marketers who want to optimize their strategy with analytics, recycling, and posting time recommendations. From $25/month ($20 billed annually) — or free for basic use — it provides strong analytical value alongside competent scheduling. For Pinterest marketers who want to skip manual pin creation entirely, automated tools like BlogToPin complement either scheduler by generating pins from your existing content.
Want pins created automatically?
Both Buffer and Metricool require manual pin creation. BlogToPin generates pins from your website with AI — no design work needed.
Frequently Asked Questions
7 questions answered about Buffer vs Metricool
Is Metricool's free plan good enough for Pinterest?
Yes, for small-scale Pinterest management. You get one brand, up to 20 posts per month, and basic analytics at no cost. Metricool has no free trial of paid plans, so the free tier is the way to test it.
Does Metricool recommend the best times to pin?
Yes. Metricool analyzes your Pinterest audience's activity and suggests optimal posting times. These suggestions are based on your actual data, not generic recommendations, making them more relevant than one-size-fits-all timing advice.
Can Metricool track competitor Pinterest accounts?
No. Metricool has competitor tracking, but it does not cover Pinterest. Buffer has no competitor tracking at all. To benchmark Pinterest competitors, search your target keywords on Pinterest and study the top-ranking pins manually.
Does Buffer plan to add deeper analytics?
Buffer has historically focused on scheduling simplicity rather than analytics depth. Its product philosophy favors doing fewer things well. Users who need deeper Pinterest analytics typically pair Buffer with a dedicated analytics tool or Pinterest's native dashboard.
Can Metricool recycle evergreen pins?
Yes. Metricool's Autolists recycle evergreen content on a schedule, which suits Pinterest pins that keep driving traffic for months. Buffer has no recycling — you would re-add each pin manually.
Which tool creates better Pinterest pin designs?
Neither. Both Buffer and Metricool are scheduling and analytics tools, not design tools. You need to create pin designs externally using Canva, Photoshop, or an automated pin generator like BlogToPin before uploading them for scheduling.
Can I export Pinterest analytics from Metricool?
Yes. Metricool provides downloadable reports with visual charts and performance data, including its detailed Pinterest metrics, suitable for sharing with clients or stakeholders.
Tired of creating pins by hand?
BlogToPin generates Pinterest pins from your website automatically. AI writes the titles and descriptions, 100+ templates handle design, and smart scheduling posts at optimal times. Try it free.